I get it though. I suspect one reason for much of the backlash is the hopeless tone of the movie. We want Star Wars to reassure us that evil is easy to spot and easily defeated. We want the good guys to blow up the death star while suffering few casualties, most of whom we barely ever get to know. We want optimism and joy out of these films, because that’s what they gave us as children. Especially given our toxic political climate and the despair many of us feel with regards to the bleakness of the future. If Star Wars can’t be our form of escape, what can be?
That’s the second reason I think is behind this backlash. Our heroes failed. The last shot of Return of the Jedi is a happy one. Our heroes standing together after defeating the Emperor and destroying his Death Star. Darth Vader redeemed and standing alongside the ghosts of master Yoda and Ben Kenobi. For decades, we didn’t know the details of exactly what happened after this scene, but our minds (or the expanded universe) filled those gaps. Our heroes lived happily ever after, or faced future struggles which were themselves overcome. What’s crucial is that they succeeded.
The Last Jedi shatters those illusions. We never even see the gang back together. The conflict continues and we’re left wondering what, if anything, was achieved by the victories of the original trilogy.
Han is dead. Luke is dead. Leia lives, but we all know Carrie Fisher’s death haunts her every scene throughout the film. The New Republic is gone, and our rebels are slowly being picked off. The film was psychologically taxing throughout because of the weight it imbued on the deaths of every rebel casualty. It had far more in common with Battlestar Galactica than any previous Star Wars film in its portrayal of the hopeless situation our heroes find themselves in:
In this film, Poe Dameron sort of represents the way that Star Wars has typically treated the concept of war: a heroic effort of blowing up the bad guys despite the odds and with little regard to the loss of life. Sure, we get some occasional glances and throwaway lines, but for the most part the deaths of pilots and soldiers is never an issue, and we certainly never see discussed the loss of life as it pertains to the bad guys. But in the last Jedi we’re suddenly thrust into this scenario where literally only four hundred good guys are left, and as the movie progresses we end with only a handful.
The loss of life is keenly felt. No one is cannon fodder anymore, as we start to recognize faces across scenes and realize that these are people, they’re not just cogs in a machine to bring down the bad guys. Every single person matters, so the focus really shifts from destroying the enemy to preserving life in general, which is the revelation that Luke passes on to Rey.
The force is life and the universe itself, not ideology. The Jedi don’t represent the light just as the Sith don’t represent the dark. Light and dark as good and evil are ideological, not natural. Everyone, good and evil, is part of the interconnecting and balance that holds the universe together.
The final scene in The Last Jedi marks a fork in the road where the direction of the Star Wars franchise would inevitably split the fanbase. I left the theater in tears. All I could think was “This is how my heroes died, and they didn’t even get to say goodbye.”
There is much to nitpick about this movie. It is far from perfect. Some decisions were silly, others indefensible, while others are okay to overlook. This is Star Wars after all. But I think the nitpicking masks the real underlying tension behind the polarization of the fan base. The film defied expectations, and whether you’re okay with that depends on whether the franchise is better off remaining faithful to George Lucas’s original vision or if, like me, you think it’s about time we listened to the lessons of David Brin.
I think it’s a masterpiece. But dammit, growing up is hard.
This news has been published by title Greatest Strength Of \'Solo: A Star Wars Story\' Is Also Its Biggest Weakness
If the page you admission is error or not right of entry perfectly, divert visit the native web in source CLICK HERE
Thank you for your visit to our website, hopefully the information we convey is useful, do not forget to share and subscribe our web to acquire more information.[TAG]907